Mother’s Day Moving
Friday, May 7th, 2010
In my world Catherine Keener can do no wrong and it was she–leading a perfect cast–who drew me last Sunday to Hollywood’s Arclight Cinema for writer-director Nicole Holofcener’s “Please Give,” a film much about wanting.
At the Arclight I sat through a number of trailers, one of them a documentary-as-cuddly-feature called “Babies.” Could it be that I was the only person who didn’t coo myself to nap time or dribble “aaaawwws” all over my shirt for Thomas Balmès’ trailer of what should be tears? (or, at the very least, a parity of emotional reels?–sorry for the out of hand double entendres here, equally sickening, I know). I could barely contain myself–or, more specifically, my dread of each impending frame of adorable-ness. Los Angeles Times film critic Betsey Sharkey describes it “a joyous and buoyant new documentary that has been charming audiences for months.” But some of us in the audience could barely stomach the trailer, contorting this viewer into an angry fetal position despite her comfy chair. At least Sharkey also (partially) saw it for what it was: a work of high-gloss infant air-brushing. How thrilling. Downright antsy, I couldn’t wait for it to end its slobbering screen smiles and cap the heartstrings-plucking. What was Sharkey & Company’s Bundle of Joy was yet another case of Cute porn to me–the visual equivalent of almost any John Williams-for-Spielberg score. It ended, much to my relief, after what felt like 15 minutes of Stage Parent as Important Artist, seguing into another French offering that was (thank you, Jesus), an actual piece of creative celluloid.
It was Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s “Micmacs” that served as instant posture relief. It was sheer rompy, whimsical delight, and I don’t care how many people describe it thus–it was genius compared to the treacle fest of the infantapalooza before it. I couldn’t wait to order my tickets and assert my imaginative adult self. Hooray! Filmmaking lives! I wanted to shout.
And then…the trailer for ”Letters To Juliet” appeared in all its Veronan glory–a movie starring the luminous Amanda Seyfried in what felt like a “Babies” for Young Adults. But here I was stupidly smitten–and self-berated, I can assure you. Smitten not exactly for the predictability of the storyline but for the embrace between Seyfried and Vanessa Redgrave (and…well, yes, despite the heavy-handed tone, the part about long-lost loves and second chances in Italy also did it).
But I quickly gained my composure, falling head first into “Please Give,” in which a slight embrace between an unrelated mother and daughter nearly left me drowned. Holofcener’s pitch perfection (and lack of bombastic score), complete respect and trust in her actors is the tonal difference between this and, say…almost everything else I saw this week, whether trailing before me to titillate or unfolding before me to contemplate. It is also the difference between art and artlessness. Between art and sincerely trying.
A couple nights later, I attended a screening of Rodrigo García’s “Mother & Child,” another film about wanting. García’s “Mother & Child” was at times heart-wrenching, nauseating, and perfect. Los Angeles Times film reviewer Michael Phillips and I disagree as to the amount of suds this “classy, well-acted soap opera” dispersed. The essential difference between it and Nicole Holofcener’s “Please Give” was the restraint each director possessed. Holofcener clearly owns her films; García, while so damned satisfying and tonally correct most of the time, seems to have given in to some Hollywood executive who chose to prolong the movie well past its natural ending and wrap it in a pink bow.
All of these films and trailers, I realized, were viewed during the week before that most Hallmark of holidays, Mother’s Day (I know its honorable history; it’s the present-day transmogrification of which that I am referring). “Babies,” I might add, is just the sort of trailer my mother would have fallen for; “Please Give” is the film she might have loved…and not known why.